Public-school systems in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago are considering alternatives to Google Search after the company said schools cannot disable its AI features while keeping conventional Search. Starting next year, districts that opt out of Gemini-powered search would lose Search access as well.

New York City’s schools chancellor said the district would explore other search providers if Google does not change course. Chicago reportedly delivered a similar message. The dispute follows a New York policy barring students through eighth grade from classroom AI use and wider concern that generated answers can shortcut learning.

Google says it is piloting Guided Learning, which walks students through complex problems instead of giving only a quick answer. It also says the Gemini app, Gemini Notebook and Search will be off by default for schools next year until administrators choose which services to enable. That changes the initial state but does not create a conventional Search option separated from AI.

Switching providers would be difficult because many districts also rely on Chromebooks, Google Classroom and related services. The confrontation will test whether education customers can demand unbundled access when a dominant platform treats AI as part of its core search product.